Showing posts with label rant. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rant. Show all posts

Thursday, May 19, 2016

The Hills I Will Gladly Die On

So the inevitable has happened once again. What I mean by this is that life has a habit of bringing up one topic which infuriates me to the point that it is one of the hills I will happily die on. What I mean is I will defend my stance with such fervor that the only way to quell my voice is to kill me. And there are only two topics which affects me to this extent. The anti-vaccine movement and the very idea that autism is something to cure.

Why am I talking about this? Specifically because my elder stepsister (who may as well be my big sis) is doing a paper for a college course and she needs statements from those on the autism spectrum about the anti-vaccine movement. This will be done partially as an opinion piece and partially as a piece referencing peer reviewed scholarly piece. I really have to thank my big sis for bringing up the topic since I have a final paper for Sociology 101 which (if given permission) will be about how autism and the views around it is actually a public health crisis. I hope/intend to use some of this rant as a part of that paper. I will also state that some of this will be based on the research and findings from a similar piece I wrote for English 101 about the same topic, so yes, I actually do know what I'm talking about (mostly).

The Facts

There are several concepts that I feel I should emphasize before I get into the nitty-gritty. First of all, correlation DOES NOT imply causation. Just because one variable SEEMS to influence something DOES NOT mean that there is only one source or cause. This whole concept was emphasized in my Psychology 100 class. So yes, this concept is incredibly important.

A lot of the argument extrapolates and correlates the increase of both the number of vaccinations and the number of autism diagnoses. This correlation is, in fact, correct. To many people, they declare a causal relationship and walk away. However, I deplore you to analyze this string of logic:

If an increase of vaccines is true, would it also be true that it means that children's time around physicians have also increased? If there is an increase of child-physician time, would that also mean that physicians have more of an opportunity to notice indications of autism? By not looking at implications of increased vaccines further than a simple causal relationship, I feel that a whole dimension of the situation is left ignored.

Furthermore, the whole movement is based on what is known as the Wakefield paper, a study made by Andrew Wakefield and 12 colleagues, which clearly accused the viruses which make up the MMR vaccination of remaining in their subjects' intestines. What these people fail to acknowledge was that Wakefield's study had the sample size of 12 people and no control groups. If this doesn't alarm you, then the fact that the funding of the study came from people trying to win lawsuits against caccine-producing companies and the group performing the study was later "held guilty of ethical violations (they had conducted invasive investigations on the children without obtaining the necessary ethical clearances) and scientific misrepresentation (they reported that their sampling was consecutive when, in fact, it was selective)"(Sathyanarayana). 

Another point of evidence which I feel is ignored is that studies conducted in the state of California where the rates of diagnoses and vaccinations were compared. Immunization rates only increased by 14% while autism diagnoses have increased by 373%. I have to thank the anti-vaccine movement in one huge way: without them, we wouldn't have a true control group. Studies have even compiled the rates of autism diagnoses among unvaccinated children and found NO SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE TWO GROUPS.

The Real Cause?

First of all, some types of autism seem to have a genetic link - such as the link between having an engineer in the family and Asperger's Syndrome. But there are several other variables which we have started to find.

I've recently read Emergence: Labeled Autistic by Dr. Temple Grandin which implies that some types of autism may be caused by an underdeveloped central nervous system, lack/shortage of myelin, or having a brain which is underdeveloped in some areas and overdeveloped in others.

Somewhere, I've also read that there is a relationship between gut bacteria and autistic behaviors. I've even read somewhere that there is some link between some types of autism and having 3x as many neurons in a brain 2x the size of a typical brain.

Personal Opinions

I have tried to be impartial in the previous sections. I know that it is likely I've completely failed. 

The only reason I feel that identifying the cause or source of autism is just so that we can identify autism earlier and have the ability to do more to assist those like me to become what society can accept. So that we can pioneer better therapies. But that can only do so much.

Also, this leads into the whole concept of "curing autism". My opinion is "don't". There's nothing wrong with me - nothing that is worth fixing. The only reason I'm deemed "disabled" is entirely because society is so narrow-minded and unwilling to accommodate those who speak differently or have non-verbal means of communicating. My "disability" is entirely a "social disability" imposed on me by a society and culture which refuses to change to accommodate anyone who differs from the majority. Until then, we will still be stuck with an argument between those who want to "cure" me and those like me who don't want to be cured - I've recently found that I'm not the only one who sees autism as a part of who I am, a lens that I see through to experience the world. Take that away from me and I will never be me. I will become someone else. In a sense, it would be genocide. 

Just think of it this way: every known genius, innovator, inventor have been shown to have something which makes them neurologically different from the norm. Without people like me, we wouldn't have many of the things we now take for granted. By curing autism, we would be preventing the next Einstein, Tesla, or Bill Gates from appearing and creating something society will take for granted. And hey, it could be that little child who didn't learn to speak until they were five. Or the young adult whose means of communicating with the world is a text-to-speech application on their tablet. Please just let them be them.

Sources
  • Bearman, Peter. "The roots of the vaccine panic." The American Prospect 22.3 (2011): 33+. Gale Opposing Viewpoints in Context. Web. 6 Mar. 2012.
  • Glazer, Sarah. "Increase in Autism." CQ Researcher 13 June 2003: 545-68. Web. 1 Mar. 2012.
  • Grandin, Temple, and Margaret Scariano. Emergence, Labeled Autistic. Novato, CA: Arena Press, 1986. Print.
  • Handley, J.B. "Compelling Evidence Shows That Vaccines Trigger Autism." Epidemics. David Haugen and Susan Musser, Eds. Opposing Viewpoints Series. Greenhaven Press, 2011. J.B. Handley, "Autism Is Preventable and Reversible," Larry King Live Blogs, April 2009. Reprinted by permission. Web. 3 Mar. 2012.
  • Healy, Bernadine. "Fighting the Autism-Vaccine War." U.S. News & World Report. (2008): n. page. Web. 1 Mar. 2012.
  • Keelan, Jennifer, and Kumanan Wilson. "Balancing Vaccine Science And National Policy Objectives: Lessons From The National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program Omnibus Autism Proceedings." American Journal of Public Health 101.11 (2011): 2016-2021. Academic Search Complete. Web. 1 Mar. 2012.
  • Miller, Lisa, and Joni Reynolds. "Autism And Vaccination - The Current Evidence." Journal For Specialists In Pediatric Nursing 14.3 (2009): 166-172. Academic Search Complete. Web. 1 Mar. 2012.
  • Sathyanarayana Rao, T.S,, and Chittaranjan Andrade. "The MMR vaccine and autism: Sensation, refutation, retraction, and fraud." Indian Journal of Psychiatry Apr. 2011: 95+. Academic Search Complete. Web. 1 Mar. 2012.
  • "Statement on Thimerosal." World Health Organization. World Health Organization, 2006. Web. 6 Mar. 2012.
  • Ponte, Maya. "Vying For Credibility In The US Congress: Legitimating Symbols In The Debate Over Immunization And Autism." Focaal 46 (2005): 67-78. Academic Search Complete. Web. 1 Mar. 2012.
  • Rabin, Jack. "Denying denialism." Commentary 129.6 (2010): 9+. Gale Opposing Viewpoints In Context. Web. 6 Mar. 2012.

Monday, October 11, 2010

Apologies

I apologize for not doing a post in such a long time that I really feel bad about it. But really, I've been having quite a bit on my plate lately. Last month, I had to go back to sharing the laptop with my roommate because his had to go to the shop and then the stylus for my DSi XL disappeared so now, I can't post using it. :( Much sadness.

Still, things are going good and I plan on doing more posts and more content, but seeing that I've got no followers, I'm pretty sure I'm blogging to empty space. But I intend to change that.

You see, I've been having an idea to do some reviews on things that fit with what I like: Science Fiction, Anime, and Video Games, so I figure I'll start writing up reviews in my own style about something that fits into one of these three subjects.

The thing is, I'll probably start a new blog solely for the reviews and keep this as a personal blog. This way, people don't get confused why my character keeps changing back and forth. And I can use this to announce things too and lead up to the next review. Assuming that anyone would really read this and actually follow me.

Or it could be my cynical nature acting up.

My life's slipping back to normalcy. I spent most of my money on MTG cards due to the fact that I was lured into Scars of Mirrodin. Of course, I now have several decks using fun cards from that set, including a Myr deck and a Proliferate deck. Of course, I doubt that everyone really understands what I'm talking about.

Also, I recently got into an anime called Ouran High School Host Club and I kinda liked it. A lot of it felt rushed and stuff. Like for example, the whole plot involves a tomboy dressing up as a guy without anyone knowing she's a she due to her appearance and style of clothing she wears and then is stuck in a group of guys who assumes she's a guy too. You would think such a thing would be a major plotpoint and something that wouldn't be let out until the last few episodes, right?

Wrong. The guys finds out in the first or second episode. However, them covering up her gender does become such a large portion of the series that I didn't feel completely cheated.

Then you have the random times in a few episodes where the fourth wall gets steamrolled into submission. Almost like the characters all know that they're in a show. But I'm glad it's not more than four times in 26 episodes and not every five minutes like Duel Masters. They never used that gag to the extent that it stops being funny and starts being annoying.

However, the show does have its annoyances. Like Renge, the otaku girl with a laugh that can compete with Naga's laugh from Slayers. Oh god, I hate Naga's laugh and hearing Renge's insane laughter nearly made me go crazy. And to make Renge even more annoying (if that's even possible), right after you hear her laugh, you're treated to five to ten seconds of seeing machinery start to operate and a rig that's a mechanical podium raises from any point in the floor and on it would be that annoying otaku.

Why is she even in this series beyond her episode? I mean, she contributes nothing but background information, annoying/useless advice, and a few cheap jokes. That doesn't outweigh the annoyance that is Renge. I'd have been happier if they had put her character on a bus right after her episode where she torments the Host Club. But no...they had to have her believe that she was their manager.

Yet, she is nowhere to be seen the last few episodes when the Host Club is really in trouble. What a nice "manager", no? In short, she would be much bearable if she served more a point than she did.

<_<

I just went into a review, didn't I? I haven't even done my first review and I barely showed any character...Consider this a lapse since it is one in the effing morning and I've just now started getting tired after burning off my post-LARP energy off. Or it could be the Mountain Dew I guzzled all day wearing off...Or both.

Well, I've got to go and have fun in sleepyland.

~Laters!

Saturday, August 14, 2010

Late Night Rant

I feel like an utter heel. Like I'm the world's biggest jerk. And I'm annoyed enough to go looking for something hard enough to bash my skull open. I guess I'm just having the start of a crappy day. But what do you expect when you're woken up after three hours of sleep?

In short, Roommate has me all tied up in an emotional knot.

I woke up at midnight by the sounds of Star Trek: The Next Generation after three hours of sleep. My friends know that it's one of my favorite shows, so normally, I don't mind hearing it play in the background. I do mind when it interferes with my regular scheduled shut-eye. And having high-pitched beeping from IM programs mixed in (which even in a good mood might as well be nails on a chalkboard), it seemed that the Universe was conspiring against me.

Whigh brings me to my emotional knot. I feel like a jerk for feeling hurt/annoyed because Roommate refuses to return the amount of respect that I choose to show him. When he's asleep and I'm on the laptop, I wear headphones or mute the speakers. He claims that the speakers are turned as far down as a notch above off. Yet, noise from whatever he's doing wakes me up and any shows he watches, I can hear as if the speakers are on full blast. Including when I'm doing my darndest to ignore the sounds. I got pillows clamped to my head and I can still hear stuff clearly.

And yet, I spent almost 4 whole hours trying to sleep, only to lose patience and have a mental breakdown (which happens once a blue moon). And I feel like the worst roommate on the face of this planet for letting it all out. And Roommate had done the worst things one can possibly do in regards to my breakdown: he interrupted me and pushed me away by telling me that he's too tired to deal with my emotions. The first made me angry and the second still hurts.

It just bothers me still that I try to respect him and I get disrespected and pushed away when I let out my frustration.

Am on DSi. Can't post more.

~Later!